Secured vs Unsecured Credit Cards: Which One Should You Get?

Secured vs Unsecured Credit Cards: Which One Should You Get?

The choice between a secured vs unsecured credit card isn't complicated once you understand the key differences. One requires a cash deposit. One doesn't. But the implications for your finances — and when to choose each — go deeper.

What Is a Secured Credit Card?

Requires a refundable deposit (typically $200-$500) that becomes your credit limit. Deposit $300 = $300 limit. The deposit protects the issuer — if you stop paying, they keep it. In exchange, they give you access to a credit account reporting to all three bureaus, helping you build credit history.

Who uses them: People with no credit history, damaged credit, or those recovering from bankruptcy.

What Is an Unsecured Credit Card?

Requires no deposit. The issuer extends a credit line based on your creditworthiness — your income, credit history, credit score. Your credit limit is determined by the lender and can range from $300 to $50,000+.

Who uses them: Anyone who qualifies. Most credit cards in the U.S. are unsecured.

Key Differences

• Deposit: Secured = yes ($200-$500 min). Unsecured = no.
• Credit approval: Secured = almost anyone. Unsecured = credit check required (typically 580+ minimum, 670+ for good cards).
• Credit limit: Secured = typically equal to your deposit. Unsecured = based on creditworthiness, can be much higher.
• APR: Secured = often 24-28%. Unsecured = 15-27% depending on card and score.
• Rewards: Secured = limited or none. Unsecured = often significant (1-5% cash back, travel points, etc.).

When to Choose a Secured Credit Card

You Have No Credit History

If you're 18-22 and have never had credit, a secured card is often the best starting point. You control the risk (your limit is your deposit), and you start building history immediately. After 12-18 months of perfect behavior, you graduate to unsecured cards.

Your Credit Score Is Below 620

Most unsecured cards require at least 580-620 credit score for approval. If your score is below 620, a secured card is often your only realistic entry point. Within 12-18 months your score should be in the 660-700 range — qualifying you for good unsecured cards.

When to Choose an Unsecured Credit Card

Your Score Is 670+

You qualify for good unsecured cards with genuine rewards. There's no reason to tie up a deposit when you can get a cash back card earning 1.5-2% on all purchases — worth $200-400/year on typical spending.

You Have Existing Credit History

If you have existing accounts in good standing, you likely qualify for unsecured options.

The Graduation Path

Typical secured card journey: (1) Open with $300 deposit, (2) Use for one small recurring charge monthly, (3) Pay in full every month, (4) After 12-18 months: issuer reviews for upgrade, (5) Get deposit back; card converts to unsecured.

Most important: ask your issuer to upgrade your account (rather than close and open new) so you preserve the account's age.

The Bottom Line

If you have decent credit (670+): get an unsecured card with cash back rewards. No reason to use a secured card. If you're building or rebuilding credit (below 670): a secured card is your tool. Use it right for 12-18 months, graduate, and unlock the world of unsecured cards. The deposit isn't a cost — it's a returnable investment in your credit future.

BON Credit may earn compensation from partner offers mentioned in this article.