5 Credit Score Myths That Are Costing You Real Money

5 Credit Score Myths That Are Costing You Real Money

Bad credit score advice is everywhere — from well-meaning friends to outdated blog posts. Following these myths actively hurts your score or keeps it lower than it should be. Each myth has a real dollar cost.

Myth #1: Carrying a Balance Builds Credit

The myth: You need to carry a small balance on your credit card to build credit history.

The truth: Completely false and expensive. You build credit through on-time payments and responsible utilization — not by paying interest. Whether you carry $0 or $500 balance, the payment activity is reported the same way.

The real cost: Someone with a $3,000 card at 22% APR carrying a $500 "balance to build credit" pays $110/year in unnecessary interest. Over 5 years: $550 wasted. Your score won't improve because of the balance — only from the payment history.

The fix: Use your card, pay the full statement balance every month. Never pay interest. Your credit score will be identical or better.

Myth #2: Checking Your Credit Score Hurts It

The myth: Every time you check your credit score, it goes down.

The truth: Checking your own credit score is a "soft inquiry" and has zero impact on your score. Only hard inquiries (when a lender checks for a loan application) affect your score, and even those only cost 5-10 points temporarily.

The real cost: People afraid to check their credit often have errors sitting on their reports for years. An error can cost you 50-100 points and thousands in higher interest rates. The fear of a nonexistent penalty keeps them from catching real problems.

The fix: Check your credit score as often as you want. Your credit card's app, Credit Karma, or AnnualCreditReport.com. Weekly is fine.

Myth #3: Closing Old Cards Improves Your Score

The myth: Closing cards you don't use "cleans up" your credit profile.

The truth: Closing a card does two harmful things: (1) Reduces available credit, increasing your utilization ratio, and (2) May reduce average account age. Both hurt your score.

The real cost: Someone with 3 cards ($15,000 total limit, $4,500 balance = 30% utilization) who closes their oldest card ($6,000 limit) suddenly has $9,000 available and $4,500 balance = 50% utilization. Score drops 20-40 points — potentially moving from "good" to "fair" rates on their next loan.

The fix: Keep old cards open, especially no-fee ones. Use them occasionally. Never close a card to improve your score.

Myth #4: More Credit Cards Always Hurt Your Score

The myth: Having many credit cards makes you look irresponsible.

The truth: The number of cards doesn't directly hurt your score. What matters is utilization, payment history, and age of accounts. Many people with 800+ scores have 8-12+ cards. The key is low utilization and on-time payments.

The real cost: People who avoid opening better cards miss out on $500-$1,000/year in sign-up bonuses and rewards from strategically chosen cards.

The fix: Don't open cards you don't need, but don't fear strategically chosen cards for their rewards or to lower utilization by increasing credit. The timing and spacing of new applications matters more than total count.

Myth #5: Income Affects Your Credit Score

The myth: Higher income means a better credit score.

The truth: Income is not a factor in any credit score calculation. FICO doesn't include income, employment status, savings, investments, or net worth. A billionaire with no credit history has no score. A minimum wage worker with 10 years of perfect credit card history has 800+.

The fix: Check your actual score regardless of your income situation. You might be surprised.

Bonus Myth: You Only Have One Credit Score

You have dozens of credit scores. Different scoring models (FICO 8, FICO 9, VantageScore), different bureau data, different industry scores. The score you see on Credit Karma may differ from what a mortgage lender sees by 20-30 points. Focus on the general range and direction, not a single number.

BON Credit may earn compensation from partner offers mentioned in this article.